Livestock Guardian Dogs are incredibly devoted protectors who take their job seriously. But sometimes, they can display behaviors that might seem concerning, like barking aggressively at something on the other side of a fence, yet being perfectly calm when that barrier is removed. This behavior, known as barrier frustration, is something I frequently discuss with my Maremma Sheepdog clients.

What is Barrier Frustration?

Barrier frustration occurs when dogs cannot access something they’re interested in or feel they need to investigate because a physical barrier (like a fence) prevents them. This frustration can manifest as:

• Intense barking or growling
• Lunging at the fence
• Running back and forth along the barrier
• Digging near the fence line
• Apparent aggression toward whatever is on the other side

What’s fascinating is that many dogs who display these behaviors might be completely relaxed and social when the barrier is removed. The fence itself is triggering the frustrated reaction, not necessarily what’s on the other side.

Why LGDs Are Prone to Barrier Frustration

Livestock Guardian Dogs are particularly susceptible to barrier frustration for several reasons:

1. They’re naturally territorial and have a strong drive to investigate potential threats
2. They’re bred to patrol and secure boundaries
3. They take their protection duties extremely seriously
4. Fences prevent them from fully investigating something they perceive as needing attention

For a Maremma or other LGD, a fence represents an artificial limitation on their ability to do their job. While the fence is necessary for farm management and the dog’s safety, from the dog’s perspective, it’s preventing them from fully investigating a potential threat or interest.

Redirected Aggression: When Frustration Finds Another Target

A more concerning aspect of barrier frustration is redirected aggression. This happens when a dog becomes so frustrated by something it can’t reach that it redirects that aggression toward something or someone nearby—another dog, livestock, or even a person.

This isn’t because your dog is “bad” or naturally aggressive. It’s simply that its frustration level has reached a point where it needs to release that energy, and unfortunately, it directs it toward whatever is available.

A Real-Life Success Story: Daxo and Maggie

I recently worked with a client whose Maremma, Daxo (whom she bought from me), would become extremely agitated when he spotted stray dogs or predators outside the fence during nighttime or early morning hours. In his frustration, Daxo would turn and attack his partner LGD, Maggie.

Daxo is an excellent guardian who gets along well with Maggie during normal circumstances. His redirected aggression was situational, triggered by his inability to address potential threats outside the fence.

The solution was simple: we separated Daxo and Maggie at night, placing them in side-by-side pastures. This arrangement allowed each dog to:

• Maintain their guarding duties
• Have a break from each other
• Prevent Daxo from redirecting his frustration onto Maggie

During daylight hours, when fewer predators were active, they remained together to work as a team. This solution immediately worked, resolving the issue without complicated training protocols or medication. 

Managing Barrier Frustration in Your LGDs

If you’re seeing barrier frustration in your Livestock Guardian Dogs, here are several strategies that can help:

1. Create Visual Barriers

Sometimes, what a dog can’t see won’t trigger frustration. Consider adding visual barriers like:

• Privacy slats in chain-link fencing
• Shade cloth along fence lines
• Strategic vegetation planting to block sight lines
• Solid fencing in key areas where triggers frequently appear

2. Create Buffer Zones

If possible, create buffer zones between your primary fencing and areas where triggers appear:

• Double fencing with space between
• Wider perimeter paths around enclosures
• “No-go” zones that put distance between your dogs and boundary lines

3. Implement Separation Strategies

As we did with Daxo and Maggie, strategic separation can prevent redirected aggression:

• Rotate dogs through different areas
• Separate dogs during high-risk times (night for many predators)
• Pair less reactive dogs together
• Give highly territorial dogs their own space when needed

4. Enrichment and Distraction

A mentally stimulated dog is less likely to fixate on fence-line triggers:

• Provide plenty of appropriate activities
• Rotate toys and enrichment items
• Consider puzzle feeders
• Make homemade toys and puzzles out of empty delivery boxes, soda bottles, and milk jugs. The containers can be stuffed with treats for the dog to discover as they have fun destroying them. It’s a bit messy, but a free enrichment activity.
• Create varied terrain within enclosures to encourage natural patrolling behavior

5. Counter-Conditioning (For Some Dogs)

While LGDs have strong instincts that can be difficult to modify, some may benefit from counter-conditioning:

• Create positive associations with triggers at a distance
• Reward calm behavior when mild triggers are present
• Gradually decrease the distance to triggers as tolerance builds
• Never force interaction that causes stress

When to Seek Professional Help

While barrier frustration is normal, some situations warrant professional intervention:

• If redirected aggression causes serious injuries
• If the dog can’t be safely managed with environmental changes
• If the behavior suddenly develops in a previously calm dog
• If the behaviors escalate despite your management efforts

The Bottom Line

Barrier frustration in Livestock Guardian Dogs is a normal behavior rooted in their protective instincts and not a sign of a “bad” dog. Most cases can be successfully managed through environmental modifications, strategic separation, and understanding that your LGD is simply trying to do its job, even when limited by fences.

Remember that each dog is an individual. What works for one may not work for another, so be prepared to try different approaches until you find what works for your farm’s guardian team.

Have you experienced barrier frustration with your Livestock Guardian Dogs? What solutions have worked for you? I’d love to hear your experiences in the comments below.

Want more practical tips for managing Livestock Guardian Dogs? Sign up for our email newsletter for regular training and management advice tailored specifically for working farm dogs.